Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues. Although there are many sides to the topic, the issue has divided the majority of people to the two extreme views of the topic —Pro-choice Vs. We can see the main arguments of each side just by analyzing the titles given to the two sides. Those who are pro-life believe that they are in fact Pro-Life and that abortion is murder.
In the case of the anti-abortion, male, whose written papers on the Catholic take on the matter, there was little to no mention of any concern to the pregnant woman. This is not to say that Noonan has no regard for the well being of females, but it does speak of the logic employed in his argument.
There is a clear case of tunnel vision here, and the rather out of place comparisons he brings forth to make his points certainly do not help his cause. On the hand, Thomson makes her case considering both the state of the fetus, as well as the woman carrying it.
I find your take on the violinist metaphor to be spot on, though in my own opinion, I find the metaphor to lie in the extreme.
Additionally, I found it to be a really good idea to mention the famous case of Roe v Wade, as it provides meaningful context for this discussion, and gives one an idea about where we, as a country, stand on this matter.
Josh Bainnson November 14, at 8: I also feel that us reading a piece pro-choice by a woman and pro-life by a man makes a difference in the perspectives by both.
It would be interesting to find a piece that is pro-life from a woman, to see if there are mentions of the well-being and safety of the females or if they are also left out altogether in all pro-life arguments. The main piece of her argument is that the woman does not have any responsibility to support the fetus if it could not be supported and sustained on its own.
I do agree with you that the analogy with the violinist is a little extreme as when a woman is pregnant, she in most cases is still able to go on through her life in almost all of the same ways as before other than feeling under the weather at times, some dietary restrictions and behavioral restrictions unlike in the analogy in which the person was strapped into bed for her whole nine months.
Overall, I still stand and believe that Thomson has made a good argument for abortion. Maxwell Solasz December 3, at 5: Though when juxtaposing both sides, there is a frightening, borderline callous, attitude that proponents, of the pro-life side, Noonan included, approach the pregnant women with.
In the majority of the cases that have been brought up there is still a modicum of responsibility in the mother for the fetus. Laurel Sutherland December 2, at 9: Just as the person in bed is attached to the violinist and cannot escape, a mother carrying a fetus becomes attached in a different way to the fetus.
She becomes emotionally attached to the fetus even though it has not been born yet. It is not uncommon for mothers who intend to give their babies up for adoption to be unable to do so after the birth of their child.
They become so invested — sometimes even unconsciously — in the lives of their children that they are unable to let go. Tiffany Ahn December 8, at While the person in bed is attached to the violinist, the violinist did not agree to have the person plugged into him.
Thomson states that you are not wrong to unplug yourself even if it means that the person may die. Regarding pregnancies according to the article from Abbate, it is morally impermissible to terminate a pregnancy after the eighth week because of the fact that the fetus is a sentient being.
For example, the idea is similar to if a person decides to buy a puppy as a pet. They are aware of the fact of the responsibilities that come with owning the animal. The pregnant woman can decide up until the 8th week to get an abortion because the fetus is not yet considered a sentient being.
She has a timeframe to accept or reject the responsibilities. Leave a Reply You must be logged in to post a comment.Noonan vs. Thomson: Both Sides of Abortion Analyzed Posted on November 8, by Josh Bainnson | 5 Comments This week as we enter into applied ethics we are discussing the highly controversial topic of abortion.
Abortion Essay Analytical Free Essay Template. Free Essay Examples, Essay Formats, Writing Tools and Writing Tips. Essay analyzing the book 'How to Argue About Abortion' by John Noonan.
Essay also analyzes the topic of Pro-Choice Vs. Pro-Life.. (, December 24). Essay also analyzes the topic of Pro-Choice Vs. Pro-Life..
Buy an original custom written review on Essay analyzing the book 'How to Argue About Abortion' by John Noonan. John Noonan is an abbot supporter of the pro-life movement and in his essay, How to Argue About Abortion, he provides many arguments to support his theory that abortion is nothing but the destruction of a living, breathing human being.
Pro Choice Persuasive Essay. Abortion. A word that everyone has heard and said at one time or another. Essay analyzing the book 'How to Argue About Abortion' by John Noonan. Essay also analyzes the topic of Pro-Choice Vs. Pro-Life.5/5(7).