California recently joined Oregon, Washington, Vermont, and Montana in legalizing physician-assisted suicide. Death, like taxes, is inevitable. But should we be able to turn to doctors to help us die? Micco explores the complex ethical and legal issues involved.
They argue that society should respect and defer to the freedom of choice such people exercise in asking to be killed. However, the consequences of accepting this perspective need to be carefully examined.
If suicide and physician-assisted suicide become legal rights, the presumption that people attempting suicide are deranged and in need of psychological help, borne out by many studies and years of experience, would be reversed.
Those seeking suicide would be legally entitled to be left alone 1 to do something irremediable, based on a distorted assessment of their circumstances, without genuine help. An attempt at suicide, some psychologists say, is often a challenge to see if anyone really cares about the person seeking help.
Few people, if any, simply make a cool, rational decision to commit suicide.
LouisMissouriDr. Suicide is often a desperate plea by individuals who consider their problems intractable and hopeless. Experts in psychology recognize that these individuals make flawed evaluations of their personal situations.
The suicidal person suffering from depression typically undergoes severe emotional and physical strain. Studies and descriptions of suicide attempters whose attempts were thwarted by outside intervention or in some cases, because the means used in the attempt did not take complete effect demonstrate that most suicidal individuals have neither an unequivocal nor an irreversible determination to die.
Suicide is their means, not their end. Often, suicide attempters are apparently seeking to establish some means of communication with significant people in their lives 17 or to test the affection of their loved ones.
Depression can be treated. Alcoholism can be overcome. The difficult situations and circumstances of life that, at the moment, seem permanent and pervasive, often dissolve or resolve in time.
Few of those rescued from suicide attempts try again. The fact that so few, once rescued and treated, ever actually go on to commit suicide lends credence to the theory that most individuals attempting suicide are ambivalent, temporarily depressed, and suffering from treatable disorders.
They argue that the only way to alleviate the pain is to eliminate the patient. The better response to patients in pain is not to kill them, but to ensure that their pain is managed and controlled. We frequently see patients referred to our Pain Clinic who request physician-assisted suicide because of uncontrolled pain.
We commonly see such ideation and requests dissolve with adequate control of pain and other symptoms, using combinations of pharmacologic, neurosurgical, anesthetic, or psychological approaches.
Severe Pain Proper administration of an opioid, particularly morphine, has been proven to provide effective pain management in the majority of patients with severe pain. Some patients may benefit from radiation therapy, nerve blocks including even spino-thalamic tractotomy in selected casesnon-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and non-pharmacological methods, which include distraction and relaxation.
One of these, Patient Controlled Analgesia PCA a pump which can deliver a continuous infusion of a drug such as morphine, as well as allow patient-activated doses for breakthrough paineliminates any delays in pain relief.Instead of embracing physician-assisted suicide, we should respond to suffering with true compassion and solidarity.
People seeking physician-assisted suicide typically suffer from depression or. If suicide and physician-assisted suicide become legal rights, the presumption that people attempting suicide are deranged and in need of psychological help, borne out by many studies and years of experience, would be reversed.
The Top 10 Reasons Euthanasia Should be Illegal. Top 10 Reasons Euthanasia Should be Illegal In recent decades, there has been much of talk regarding euthanasia, the . Assisted suicide undermines equality, liberty, medical care, and the power of suicide.
There's also a host of potential unintended consequences. Taken together, all of these points make a compelling case that assisted suicide should remain illegal. Terminally ill patients should have the right to assisted suicide because it is the best means for them to end the pain caused by an illness which no drug can cure.
A competent terminal patient must have the option of assisted suicide because it is in the best interest of that person. (Barnard 28).
The oath makes the physician promise to. But should we be able to turn to doctors to help us die? Micco explores the complex ethical and legal issues involved. First, what exactly do we mean by the term physician-assisted suicide?
Assisted suicide is the act of intentionally killing yourself with the aid of someone who provides the knowledge or .